- Do you believe in 'anything'?
- ethics, politics etc
- something there? Nothing! No supernatural, no ghosts, no telepathy, no superstitutions
- where do you get Spirituality from?
- deeply held beliefs, feelings about nature, deep convictions
- no god, bad idea to believe in god and its been very harmful for man to believe in god
- Believing in God then becoming an atheist
- bible got me into philosophy
- metaphysical and divine (what does it all mean) and ethics of New Testament got me interested in philosophy
- studied pychology at Uni - religion just disappeared - its a load of rubbish
- read Bertrand Rusell; keep ethical side and jetison the rest (miracles, origin of universe, virgin birth)
- i would like religion to be true: cosmic justice would be good - but its not there
- bracing and hygienic with no god
- Why i dont believe in God as a philosopher
- no evidence - no reason to believe in god than in Zeus
- miracles - no good evidence
- reasons to believe in God
- Anselm - definition of God - ontological arguement
- most perfect, powerful conceivable being
- if did not exist then a more perfect being
- existence is one of the perfections of god
- what is perfect being? perfect colours?
- Unicorn - horse with one horn
- without god life is meaningless
- empty sharade
- without a being outside life
- values and meanings is evidence - that something ie god has given us these - why should values depend on existence of god
- morality foundation - Plato Euthrethro
- why wrong to steal? Socrates intrinsically sound. Murder is right?
- god cannot make something right when it is not right
- guilt is a bad feeling - god gives extra motive to do right - i dont believe that
- god will reward you is a corrupting idea - not what morality is about
- reasons to not believe in god
- problem of suffering and pain in world, why does he not interfere in death of a child - all good and powerful - conflict between that and evil, problem is free will arguement - natural catastrophies occur - god created a world in which inevitable that humans would
- god testing people - improve moral character - god should not allow this to happen
- why do people have a need to believe?
- death - cosmic loneliness - human consciousness is sealed off
- atheist is an accusation not a conviction
- label atheist - is negative - no point in spending time
- antitheism - opposition to theism - actively opposed to it - not just an atheist cf post theism and post atheism
- ideal society would be that religion was just historical - post theist society
Monday, January 28, 2008
The Atheism Tapes with Jonathan Miller - talks to Colin McGinn
Jonathan Miller talks to the philosopher Prof. Colin McGinn about atheism and anti-Theism. This interview was done for the BBC series Atheism: A rough history of disbelief. Watch the 27 minute interview. Main points in highly abbreviated format (to wet your appetite!). Don't read my rough notes - just listen to Colin McGinn talking to Jonathan Miller!!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment